Internal Control · 2024
In this section9 topics
- Internal Control — Board Opinion1 item
- Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System1 item
- Internal Control Deficiencies1 item
- Audit Committee & Auditor Observations2 items
- Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit1 item
- Related Party Transactions1 item
- Counterparties & Transactions4 items
- Policy & Future Trends1 item
Internal Control — Board Opinion
Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control
The Board of Directors realizes the importance of having a good internal control system and considers it an important duty to carry out to ensure that the Company has an appropriate and sufficient internal control system to oversee operations to be effectively in accordance with the goals, objectives, laws and related regulations, to protect assets from corruption and damage, and to prepare accurate, reliable accounts and financial reports, and to fully and adequately disclose information within an appropriate timeframe. As such, the Board of Directors has assigned the Audit Committee to conduct audits and evaluate the efficiency of the Company's internal control system and operations by working with the internal audit unit and external auditors, including examining compliance with recommendations in internal control system assessment reports received from various units in order to improve and correct weaknesses in operations process for maximum efficiency. In doing so, the Audit Committee's performance reports are prepared and submitted to the Board of Directors and reported in the Company's annual reports.
At the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 1/2567 on 11 January 2024, which 3 members of the Audit Committee attended as independent directors, the Board of Directors considered approving the appointment of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Jaiyos Audit Co., Ltd. to be the internal auditor of the Company and its subsidiaries for the year 2024 in order to review the internal control system and monitor improvements to the internal control system of the Company and subsidiaries. In doing so, the internal auditors present internal audit reports to the Audit Committee, and prepare the annual internal audit plan to be submitted to the Audit Committee meeting for consideration and approval for use in monitoring and evaluating the accuracy and completeness of work in accordance with the plans and policies set by the Company. In any case, the Company continuously improves and develops the effectiveness of its internal control system.
Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System
Internal Control Framework Used
| Framework | Detail |
|---|---|
| COSO - Enterprise Risk Management Framework (ERM) | In 2024, the Board of Directors assessed the Company’s internal control system based on the review results of the Audit Committee, jointly conducted its review with external auditors. The Board of Directors thus has the opinion that the Company’s internal control system is adequate and appropriate. The Company has also assigned personnel to effectively carry out internal control activities, and an internal control system exists for monitoring and control covering the protection of the Company’s and subsidiaries’ assets from loss or improper use, not to mention transactions with persons with conflicts of interest and related persons. This helps to ensure that the Company’s and its subsidiaries’ financial reports are accurate and reliable. In addition, the Audit Committee has no differences in opinions from the Board of Directors’ opinions regarding internal control, by which the Company and its subsidiaries have an adequate and appropriate internal control system covering 5 aspects, namely, control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information and communication, and monitoring and evaluation system, in line with the SEC's assessment of the adequacy of internal control systems. A summary of the main points by component of internal control according to the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of Treadway Commission (“COSO”) is as follows: (1) Internal Control Environment The Company has effective and appropriate internal control, and executives have support and promote a corporate culture that focuses on ethics and honesty, in addition to having a clear structure of management and work assignments as follows: (a) The Company has established a written policy on good corporate governance and business ethics and has communicated it to all directors, executives and employees so that employees in the organization strictly comply with it. (b) The Company has clearly defined the roles and responsibilities of the Board of Directors to be separate from the management and has established an organizational structure, chain of command, and authority and responsibility that are appropriate and consistent with the business environment. (c) The Company has established written policies regarding human resource management, such as recruitment, training and compensation. (2) Risk Assessment The Company gives importance to risk management to ensure steady and stable business growth by adopting a risk management system in accordance with the COSO standard to be able to control risks at an acceptable level. Furthermore, the Board of Directors has also appointed a Risk Management Committee consisting of 5 members, most of whom are independent directors who have the qualifications as specified by the SEC and have the appropriate knowledge, abilities, and experience, to set policies and operational frameworks. This includes considering key risks such as management risks, financial risks, information security risks, legal and regulatory risks, etc. and also providing guidelines for prevention and reducing risk levels to an acceptable level along with monitoring and improvement of operational plans to be in line with business situations, with meetings set to take place every quarter along with reporting to the Board of Directors. In addition, the Company has established a Risk Management Working Group comprising senior executives and managers from each unit to be responsible for efficiently and effectively identifying, analyzing, evaluating and managing risks at both the unit and organization levels, as well as for promoting risk management as part of the organization's culture by communicating policies and creating a manual for all employees to have awareness about potential risks and to jointly play a role in preventing or reducing risks that may affect the organization. (3) Control Activities The Company has arranged for control activities to take place through various policies and operating procedures, such as the policy on control and supervision of subsidiaries and affiliated companies, an authority manual and the charters of the Board of Directors and subcommittees. Furthermore, the Company also collects information on major shareholders, directors, executives and related persons to monitor and examine transactions that may have conflicts of interest by using technology systems to control and protect data security, including assigning access rights for specific individuals only. (4) Information and Communication System The Company has an efficient information system and communication channels both inside and outside the organization. Executives and employees can receive news and information via email and the Company's activity announcement area. In addition, the Company consistently discloses relevant information to stakeholders, and the information disclosed is true, correct and complete, and is disclosed through various channels, such as the website of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and the Company’s website. In addition, the Company has provided special channels for employees and external parties to report information about illegal activities or regulation violations and has established measures to protect whistleblowers to ensure that complaints are considered transparently, fairly and confidentially within an appropriate period of time. (5) Monitoring Activities System The Company monitors and evaluates the adequacy of internal controls by reviewing internal control system compliance every quarter. Such reviews are conducted by internal auditors who are been selected by the Audit Committee, and they report audit results directly to the Audit Committee. In addition, annual internal control assessments take place in accordance with the guidelines of the SEC to ensure that the Company's internal controls are adequate and appropriate, with the Company taking immediate action to correct any faults discovered. |
Internal Control Deficiencies
Number of Deficiencies
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Audit Committee & Auditor Observations
Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's
No
Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control
No
Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
Head of Internal Audit
3159
Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
the Audit Committee has ensured that the Company has an internal audit supervisor with appropriate educational qualifications, experience and training to perform duties, and has considered the independence of the internal audit unit from the performance of duties and various reports. The committee also approved the appointment, removal, transfer or termination of the head of the internal audit unit or external auditor responsible for internal auditing, by which the Audit Committee Meeting No. 13/2566 on 19 October 2023 resolved to appoint Miss Amaraphon Homsombat to the position of head of internal audit of the Company from 19 October 2023 onwards for her to act as the primary person responsible for performing the duties of the Company's internal auditor, due to her experience in internal auditing and her training in courses related to the supervision of such operations, in addition to her as having an understanding of the Company's activities and operations. Thus, it was deemed fitting for her to perform the aforementioned duties as appropriate and adequate. (Please consider additional details about the Company's internal audit head in Attachment 3 – Information about the Head of Internal Audit)
Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit
Requires Audit Committee Approval
Yes
Related Party Transactions
Has Related Party Transactions
Yes
Counterparties & Transactions
Introduction
The Company has conducted transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest. The related person transactions are transactions conducted with the directors and/or executives and/or shareholders of the Company and related companies. The nature of the relationships can be summarized as follows:
Monetary Unit
1000000
Counterparties with Potential Conflicts
| Name | Person / Juristic Person | Type of Business | Nature of Relationship | As of Date (YYYY-MM-DD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo | Person | Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo directly holds shares in the Company by 22.63 percent of the Company's paid-up registered capital and is a controlling person. | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| Miss Napatsorn Yutinatorn | Person | She holds the position of Chief Marketing Officer and is the daughter of Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo. | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| Miss Jintana Chinpinkyo | Person | She is a director of Chow-Aree Holding Co., Ltd., a juristic person with the power to control the Company's business, and she is a sibling of Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo. | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| Mr. Pitiwat Chinpinkyo | Person | He is a director of Chow-Aree Holding Co., Ltd., a juristic person with the power to control the Company's business, and is a sibling of Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo. | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| Mr. Phanuwat Chinpinkyo | Person | He is a director of Chow-Aree Holding Co., Ltd., a juristic person with the power to control the Company's business, and is a sibling of Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo. | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| Just Like and More Co., Ltd. | Juristic Person | Engage in commercial business / Conduct business operations. | This is a joint venture company in which Thai Coconut Public Company Limited directly holds 59.9985 percent of shares. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Harmony Agri Business Co., Ltd. | Juristic Person | Engage in commercial business / Conduct business operations. | This is a juristic person in which a related person of the director of the juristic person who has the power to control the Company's business holds more than 30 percent of the shares. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Mission to Nirvana Co., Ltd. | Juristic Person | Engage in commercial business / Conduct business operations. | Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo is an authorized signatory director and holds 99.95 percent of the Company's paid-up registered capital and is a controlling person. Miss Chanya Thanasakdiphat is the spouse of Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo and holds 0.05 percent of the Company's paid-up registered capital. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Control G Solution Co., Ltd. | Juristic Person | Engage in commercial business / Conduct business operations. | This is a juristic person in which Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo holds shares indirectly through NEX Corporation Co., Ltd. in the proportion of 20 percent of the Company's paid-up registered capital, and Miss Chanya Thanasakdiphat, Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo's spouse, holds shares indirectly through NEX Corporation Co., Ltd. in the proportion of 40 percent of the Company's paid-up registered capital. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Miss Chanya Thanasakdiphat | Person | She is the spouse of Dr. Worawat Chinpinkyo. | 2024-12-31T00:00 | |
| Miss Pichamon Wongthawisap | Person | She is a person related to the directors of Chaow-Ari Holding Company Limited, which is a juristic person with the power to control the Company's business. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
Transactions by Counterparty
| Transactions |
|---|
| 0.44 · Necessity: The Company entered into a contract to lease office space on the 2nd floor of Building 2, with parking and facilities, with Control G Solution Co., Ltd., to use as a place of work for the employees of the said company, and entered into a contract to lease seminar room space on the 8th floor of Building 2, along with parking and facilities with Mission to Nirvana Co., Ltd. to use as a place for meetings, training and seminars. The agreed rental price is based on the appraisal price of Sims Property Consultant Co., Ltd., a capital market asset valuation company approved by the SEC. The Company charged a monthly rental fee from Control G Solution Co., Ltd. at the rate of 40,000 baht per month and a per-time rental fee from Mission to Nirvana Co., Ltd. at the rate of 5,000 baht per time. The rental period is from 1 May 2024 to 30 April 2025. The lessee has the right to extend the lease for another year with the approval of the lessor. However, if the lessee wishes to terminate the lease before the expiration of the lease period, the lessee must notify the lessor by at least 1 month in advance. · Description: Rental income · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Rental income · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee considered that the rental fees of the Company's office space with Control G Solution Co., Ltd. and Mission to Nirvana Co., Ltd. were reasonable, with the rental rates as referenced from and compared to the appraised price of Sims Property Consultant Co., Ltd., a capital market asset appraisal company approved by the SEC. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 |
| 0.05 · Necessity: The Company entered into a contract to lease office space on the 2nd floor of Building 2, with parking and facilities, with Control G Solution Co., Ltd., to use as a place of work for the employees of the said company, and entered into a contract to lease seminar room space on the 8th floor of Building 2, along with parking and facilities with Mission to Nirvana Co., Ltd. to use as a place for meetings, training and seminars. The agreed rental price is based on the appraisal price of Sims Property Consultant Co., Ltd., a capital market asset valuation company approved by the SEC. The Company charged a monthly rental fee from Control G Solution Co., Ltd. at the rate of 40,000 baht per month and a per-time rental fee from Mission to Nirvana Co., Ltd. at the rate of 5,000 baht per time. The rental period is from 1 May 2024 to 30 April 2025. The lessee has the right to extend the lease for another year with the approval of the lessor. However, if the lessee wishes to terminate the lease before the expiration of the lease period, the lessee must notify the lessor by at least 1 month in advance. · Description: Other debtors · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other debtors · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee considered that the rental fees of the Company's office space with Control G Solution Co., Ltd. and Mission to Nirvana Co., Ltd. were reasonable, with the rental rates as referenced from and compared to the appraised price of Sims Property Consultant Co., Ltd., a capital market asset appraisal company approved by the SEC. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 |
| 0.08 · Necessity: The Company recognizes the importance of of sustainable business operations. and strengthening good relationships with communities, coconut farmers, provincial government agencies and local government agencies to build trust and understanding with the community and the environment and promotes income for farmers and communities in Ratchaburi Province. Such social activities mentioned above are important for the Company to operate a sustainable business. Therefore, it was necessary to have a consultant who has knowledge and good relationships with the community and local government agencies. Miss Jintana Chinpinkyo had all of the above qualifications. Thus, the Company hired her as a consultant and paid her consulting fees for social activities and other work by a total amount of 80,000 baht per month (1 January 2024 - 31 December 2024 and 1 January 2023 - 31 December 2023), and in 2024, Miss Jintana Chinpinkyo prepared a letter to cancel the consulting contract, effective from 1 February 2024 onwards. · Description: Consulting fee · As of yesteryear: 0.96 · Nature of transaction: Consulting fee · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee considered that the consulting fee was reasonable and were transactions to obtain specific advice based on expertise. |
| 0.96 · Necessity: The Company experienced continuous growth in business and sales. Therefore, the Company expanded the factory and production capacity to meet the needs of customers. The Company focused on the procurement for the construction of the factory, warehouse and, renewable energy projects to reduce global warming along with the procurement of quality coconut raw materials at reasonable prices to increase production cost control capabilities. As such, the Company needed a person with knowledge and expertise in engineering and coconut raw materials as a consultant. Mr. Pitiwat Chinpinkyo had all of these qualifications. Therefore, the Company hired him as a consultant and paid a consultant fee at the total amount of 80,000 baht per month (1 January 2024 - 31 December 2024 and 1 January 2023 - 31 December 2023). · Description: Consulting fee · As of yesteryear: 0.96 · Nature of transaction: Consulting fee · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee considered that the consulting fee was reasonable and were transactions to obtain specific advice based on expertise. |
| 0.96 · Necessity: The Company is engaged in the business of producing and distributing coconut milk, coconut water, and other products. Therefore, the Company needed to have people with knowledge and skills in labor laws, social security and the laws related to factory laws governing work safety, occupational health and work environment. Mr. Phanuwat Chinpinkyo had all of the above qualifications. As a result, the Company hired him as a consultant and paid consulting fees on safety, occupational health and work environment and other works by the total amount of 80,000 baht per month (1 January 2024 to 31 December 2024) and 1 January 2023 to 31 December 2023). · Description: Consulting fee · As of yesteryear: 0.96 · Nature of transaction: Consulting fee · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee considered that the consulting fee was reasonable and were transactions to obtain specific advice based on expertise. |
| 0.75 · Necessity: The Company recognizes that employees are important assets. Accordingly, business is currently changing rapidly, and self-awareness, understanding about the worldviews of others thought management, acceptance of changes, communication skills, relationship building with people at all levels of the organization, inspiring work, and compassionate and effective leadership skills are employee qualities that help drive the organization to sustainable success. The Leader & Trainer Program: Empowering Organizational Catalysts of Mission to Nirvana Co., Ltd. was a program that helped instill these skills in full. Mission to Nirvana Co., Ltd. is a company that accepts the general public to participate in training, and the Company views that the program was useful. Therefore, employees were sent to attend the training by paying the same training fee as the general public. · Description: Training fee and Prepaid Expenses · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Training fee and Prepaid Expenses · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee considerd that the training expenses were necessary and reasonable and that the program would help to instill good behavior and attitudes in employees in the organization, which was beneficial to the Company's business operations. Moreover, the training fees were paid at the same rate as the general public. |
| 0.28 · Necessity: Since the Company made investment in machinery, equipment and systems in the production line and invested in building a warehouse to support the expansion of production capacity and storage of coconut products according to the increasing orders from customers, the Company needed to manage the space within the factory to create maximum benefits by changing the parking space within the factory to be used as a warehouse and a substation, which supported commercial business beyond merely using the space for parking. This also managed the risks to both employees and other assets in the factory from the density of traffic within the Company due to the Company's growth. · Description: Land rent · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Land rent · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee considered that the land lease transaction was necessary and reasonable and was of the utmost benefit to the Company, with a rental rate close to the appraisal price of the Valuation and Consultants Co., Ltd., an independent appraiser on the list of property appraisal companies approved by the SEC, according to the proposal made by the management to the Audit Committee Meeting No. 9/2567 on 12 September 2024. |
| 0.07 · Necessity: Since the Company made investment in machinery, equipment and systems in the production line and invested in building a warehouse to support the expansion of production capacity and storage of coconut products according to the increasing orders from customers, the Company needed to manage the space within the factory to create maximum benefits by changing the parking space within the factory to be used as a warehouse and a substation, which supported commercial business beyond merely using the space for parking. This also managed the risks to both employees and other assets in the factory from the density of traffic within the Company due to the Company's growth. · Description: Land rent · Nature of transaction: Land rent · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee considered that the land lease transaction was necessary and reasonable and was of the utmost benefit to the Company, with a rental rate close to the appraisal price of the Valuation and Consultants Co., Ltd., an independent appraiser on the list of property appraisal companies approved by the SEC, according to the proposal made by the management to the Audit Committee Meeting No. 9/2567 on 12 September 2024. |
| 0.06 · Necessity: Since the Company made investment in machinery, equipment and systems in the production line and invested in building a warehouse to support the expansion of production capacity and storage of coconut products according to the increasing orders from customers, the Company needed to manage the space within the factory to create maximum benefits by changing the parking space within the factory to be used as a warehouse and a substation, which supported commercial business beyond merely using the space for parking. This also managed the risks to both employees and other assets in the factory from the density of traffic within the Company due to the Company's growth. · Description: Land rent · Nature of transaction: Land rent · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee considered that the land lease transaction was necessary and reasonable and was of the utmost benefit to the Company, with a rental rate close to the appraisal price of the Valuation and Consultants Co., Ltd., an independent appraiser on the list of property appraisal companies approved by the SEC, according to the proposal made by the management to the Audit Committee Meeting No. 9/2567 on 12 September 2024. |
| 0.07 · Necessity: Since the Company made investment in machinery, equipment and systems in the production line and invested in building a warehouse to support the expansion of production capacity and storage of coconut products according to the increasing orders from customers, the Company needed to manage the space within the factory to create maximum benefits by changing the parking space within the factory to be used as a warehouse and a substation, which supported commercial business beyond merely using the space for parking. This also managed the risks to both employees and other assets in the factory from the density of traffic within the Company due to the Company's growth. · Description: Land rent · Nature of transaction: Land rent · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee considered that the land lease transaction was necessary and reasonable and was of the utmost benefit to the Company, with a rental rate close to the appraisal price of the Valuation and Consultants Co., Ltd., an independent appraiser on the list of property appraisal companies approved by the SEC, according to the proposal made by the management to the Audit Committee Meeting No. 9/2567 on 12 September 2024. |
Policy & Future Trends
Policy, Measures & Approval Process
The resolution of the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 8/2566 on 2 June 2023 considered and approved the policy of related party transactions of the Company and its subsidiaries as detailed below: In entering into any related party transactions, the Company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, B.E. 2535 (1992) (including any amendments) (the “ Securities and Exchange Act”), including the regulations, announcements, orders or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, and will comply with the requirements regarding disclosure of information on related party transactions in accordance with the criteria prescribed under the aforementioned regulations, announcement, orders or regulations, including the financial reporting standards prescribed by the Federation of Accounting Professions under Royal Patronage (“Federation of Accounting Professions”) and other relevant criteria. The measures and procedures for approving related party transactions are as follows:
(1) The Board of Directors will arrange for the consideration and approval of related party transactions, which will be screened by the Audit Committee, with primary consideration to the benefits of the Company and shareholders to ensure that such activities comply with the regulations, announcements, orders or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, and consideration will also be given to disclosures of information on related party transactions to ensure accuracy and completeness.
(2) Consideration of approval of related party transactions will take into account appropriateness in terms of value and the reasonableness of the transactions by considering various conditions in line with normal business practices in the industry and/or by making comparisons with the prices of external parties and/or the market price and/or setting prices or conditions of such to be the same as those for external parties and/or being able to demonstrate that such transactions have reasonable or fair prices or conditions, and the Company will monitor such transactions that occur.
(3) In considering the approval of a related party transactions, directors who have an interest and/or directors who are related persons in the transactions will not attend the meeting and will not have the right to vote in the consideration of approval of such transactions. This is to ensure that these transactions will not be a transfer or exchange of the Company's benefits, but rather transactions conducted with consideration to the best interest of the Company and shareholders.
(4) The Company may arrange for a person with expertise or special skills, such as an independent expert, auditor or independent property appraiser, to provide an opinion on such related transactions for consideration by the Audit and Risk Management Committee and/or the Board of Directors and/or the shareholders' meeting (whatever the case may be).
(5) The Company will prepare a summary report of related party transactions to present to the Company 's Audit and Risk Management Committee meetings and the quarterly Board of Directors’ meetings.
In conducting normal business transactions or transactions supporting normal business activities that are in accordance with general trading conditions and other related party transactions, the following principles shall be followed:
a. Related party transactions that are part of normal business activities or transactions supporting normal business activities that comply with general trading conditions The Board of Directors has the power to approve in principle that the management can approve related party transactions that are part of normal business activities or transactions that support normal business activities that are expected to occur continuously in the future, provided they are in accordance with general trading conditions between the Company and/or its subsidiaries and the directors, executives, major shareholders or related persons of the Company, after considering that such transactions are agreements with conditions of the same nature as what a reasonable person would set with a general contracting party in the same situation, with commercial bargaining power that is free from the influence of the status of the Company's directors, executives, major shareholders or related persons, and such transactions do not result in the transfer of benefits and/or it can be demonstrated that such transactions have reasonable or fair pricing or conditions. The Company will collect and prepare a summary report of such transactions to report in the quarterly meetings of the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors.
b. Related transactions in other cases aside from (a) Any related party transactionS other than those specified in (a) will be considered and commented on by the Audit Committee before being submitted to the Board of Directors and/or the shareholders’ meeting (whatever the case may be) for further consideration and approval. These transactions must be in accordance with the Securities and Exchange Act and the regulations, announcements, orders or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, and they must comply with the requirements regarding disclosure of information on related party transactions in line with the criteria specified under such regulations, announcements, orders or requirements, including the financial reporting standards specified by the Federation of Accounting Professions and other relevant criteria.
In the event that the Audit Committee does not have expertise in considering the related party transactions that may occur, the Company may arrange for a person with specialized knowledge, such as an auditor or an independent property appraiser to provide an opinion on such related party transactions for use as information to aid decision-making by the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors and/or shareholders (whatever the case may be) to ensure that said transactions are reasonable with primary consideration to the interest of the Company.

